Table 4 Rubric and criteria application to 18 implementation science studies focused on PrEP
First Author | Year | Article Title(s) | Study Design | Outcomes | Rigor | Specifica-tion | Equity | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Brant | 2020 | Integrating HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis into Family Planning Care: A RE-AIM Framework Evaluation [29] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Promising | Needs More |
Buchbinder | 2019 | Getting to Zero San Francisco: A Collective Impact Approach [35] | Needs More | Needs More | Needs More | Needs More | Best | Needs More |
Bunting | 2019 | A Guide for Designing Student-Led, Interprofessional Community Education Initiatives About HIV Risk and Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis [36] | Best | Needs More | Needs More | Best | Promising | Needs More |
2020 | Â Using a student-led, community-specific training module to increase PrEP uptake amongst at-risk populations: results from an exploratory pilot implementation [37] | |||||||
Burns | 2021 | Meet Me Where I Am: An Evaluation of an HIV Patient Navigation Intervention to Increase Uptake of PrEP Among Black Men Who Have Sex with Men in the Deep South [27] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Needs More |
Chen | 2014 | Clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis in men who have sex with men: risk calculators for real-world decision-making [30] | Needs More | Needs More | Promising | Needs More | Promising | Needs More |
Clement | 2019 | Advancing the HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis Continuum: A Collaboration Between a Public Health Department and a Federally Qualified Health Center in the Southern United States [28] | Needs More | Best | Best | Best | Best | Needs More |
Coleman | 2020 | Integrated Pharmacy and PrEP Navigation Services to Support PrEP Uptake: A Quality Improvement Project [38] | Best | Best | Best | Best | Best | Best |
Gregg | 2020 | Implementation of HIV Preexposure Prophylaxis in a Homeless Primary Care Setting at the Veterans Affairs [39] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Best | Needs More |
Havens | 2019 | Acceptability and feasibility of a pharmacist-led HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) program in the Midwestern United States [32] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Promising | Promising | Needs More |
Horack | 2020 | Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis in a Reproductive Health Setting: A Quality Improvement Project [33] | Needs More | Needs More | Needs More | Needs More | Needs More | Needs More |
Hoth | 2019 | Iowa TelePrEP: A Public-Health-Partnered Telehealth Model for HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) Delivery in a Rural State [40] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Promising | Needs More |
Khosropour | 2020 | A Pharmacist-Led, Same-Day, HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis Initiation Program to Increase PrEP Uptake and Decrease Time to PrEP Initiation [41] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Promising | Promising | Needs More |
Lopez | 2020 | Implementation of pre-exposure prophylaxis at a community pharmacy through a collaborative practice agreement with San Francisco Department of Public Health [42] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Best | Needs More |
Pathela | 2020 | The HIV Pre-exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) Cascade at NYC Sexula Health Clinics: Navigation is the Key to Uptake [43] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Needs More | Promising | Needs More |
Roth | 2020 | Integrating HIV Preexposure Prophylaxis With Community-Based Syringe Services for Women Who Inject Druges: Results from the Project SHE Demonstration Study [44] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Promising | Needs More |
Saberi | 2018 | A Simple Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) Optimization Intervention for Health Care Providers Prescribing PrEP: Pilot Study [45] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Needs More |
Tung | 2018 | Implementation of a community pharmacy-based pre-exposure prophylaxis service: a novel model for pre-exposure prophylaxis care [46] | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Best | Needs More | Needs More |
Wood | 2018 | Project ECHO: telementoring to educate and support prescribing of HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis by community medical providers [47] | Best | Needs More | Needs More | Promising | Needs More | Needs More |