Table 5 Summary of rubric and criteria revisions after each development phase
Initial review and Interviews | Delphi Round 1 | Delphi Round 2 | Piloting |
|---|---|---|---|
• Initial proposed domains: overall effectiveness, study design quality, implementation outcomes, equity impact, strategy specification, & bundled strategies • Initial proposed evidence levels: best practice, promising, emerging, undetermined, & non-recommended strategy • Initial proposed criteria for each domain | • Dropped overall effectiveness domain • Split study design quality domain into study design and rigor and limitations domain • Revised equity domain description • Combined emerging and undetermined evidence levels and renamed as more evidence needed • Reduced criteria across all domains at all evidence-levels | • Confirmed domains • Revised equity domain descriptions • Confirmed evidence levels • Reduced criteria across all domains at all evidence-levels • Revised application process | • Revised application process • Revised criteria definitions |